Side by side
| Painting | Refacing | Replacing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What changes | Color and finish | Doors, drawer fronts, veneer on frames | Everything |
| What stays | Boxes, doors, layout, countertops | Boxes, layout, countertops | Usually nothing but the room |
| Best when | Solid cabinets, dated color | Solid boxes, door style you dislike | Damaged boxes or a new layout |
| Relative cost | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
| Disruption | Doors off for part of the job | Doors replaced, frames covered | Kitchen out of service, often countertops too |
Four questions to decide
- Are the boxes solid? Check under the sink for swelling, soft spots or delamination. Damaged boxes point to replacing.
- Do you like the door style? Shaker, flat and raised-panel doors all paint well. If you hate the shape, painting won't change it.
- Does the layout work? Painting and refacing keep it. Only replacing changes it.
- How long will you stay? If you're selling soon, painting dated cabinets is usually the most cost-effective update.
Where we fit
We only paint cabinets. If refacing or replacing is the better fit for your kitchen, you'll want a cabinet installer or remodeler instead.
Hiring a painter vs. painting them yourself
Cabinets are one of the hardest DIY paint jobs. The common failures are skipped degreasing (paint peels near the stove and sink), no bonding or stain-blocking primer (chipping, or tannin spots on oak), brush and roller marks on doors, and doors rehung before the paint has hardened (sticking and peeling at the edges). A kitchen also has more pieces than most people expect; counting doors, drawer fronts and panels is a good reality check before you start.
Questions
Can you paint cabinets that are already painted?
Yes, if the existing paint is sound. Peeling or flaking paint has to be removed where it is failing before new primer and paint go on.
Is painting cabinets worth it before selling a house?
Often, when the cabinets are dated but in good shape. It updates the kitchen for listing photos and showings without the cost of new cabinets.